| EUROPE:
LIKE IT OR NOT, IT EXISTS.
Yet again, a Mec Vannin
initiative has
left Central Government floundering and confused. So much so, that both
Miles Walker and Donald Gelling have resorted to making some pretty
pathetic
retorts.
The line from both men (they'd
obviously
discussed this one at length) was that it was strange that a
nationalist
party should be "looking toward Europe". The inference is clearly that
Mr. Walker and Gelling do not perceive France, Germany etc. to be real
nations.
What are we supposed to do?
Pretend that
there's just a big bright patch of ocean east of Dover? No.
Mec Vannin will leave that sort
of thinking
to the Yesterday Men of the current government. Europe's influence upon
Mannin is and will continue to be substantial irrespective of our
relationship
with Europe at any time. It is, therefore, essential that Mannin, be it
via Mec Vannin or the government, continue to negotiate and bargain for
whatever deals and concessions can be obtained from Europe.
That means talking to Europe
directly,
not through some third party with little or no interest in our best
interests.
If Mannin becomes totally independent, and that is an increasing
possibility,
we must make some very important and properly informed decisions
regarding
our international associations.
Another line from the
increasingly desperate
Mr. Walker, in relation to European funding was, "We should stand on
our
own two feet, not rely on hand outs from larger neighbours."
Three days later it was revealed
that Walker
and Co. had to hand back £750,000 Euro-cash, granted to aid the
abandoned
IRIS wetlands project. It also sits awkwardly with the findings of the
Council of Ministers' Report on low incomes which
recommended that, rather than
standing
on their own two feet with the right to work and earn a minimum wage,
those
on low income should be forced to rely on handouts from their wealthier
neighbours.
Finally, Mec Vannin has been
accused on
more than one occasion of scare-mongering in relation to the future of
the finance industry, Europe and Mannin. Illiam Costain's report
contains
the facts, first hand from European officials, that show that the
dangers
are very real and approaching rapidly.
The sorry old line that "Protocol
Three
is the best of both worlds" has been wheeled out once too often.
Protocol
Three means paying through the nose to comply with European standards
for
exportable goods, and getting no assistance whatsoever.
Mec Vannin's ongoing
investigations with
Europe may reveal that our future lies in trading elsewhere entirely,
but
we can't tell until we have talked to Brussels in the manner of an
independent
nation.
THINK
LOCAL? THINK MANX!
It's good to see Mec Vannin's
"Think Manx"
policy has finally been adopted by Manx business and commerce and
endorsed
by Government (of course, all Government's best policies come from Mec
Vannin).
In these days of eroded national
identity
it would be too much to expect that we would have a "Think Manx"
campaign;
nowadays in the language of business and politics, Manx has been
replaced
by "local" just as the "Isle of Man" and "Mannin have been replaced by
the "Island". However, the name of the policy is not the most important
aspect so we'll just have to make do with "Think Local".
So what exactly does "think
local" mean?
To nationalists, it means that where ever a suitable Manx resource
exists
it should be used in preference to non-Manx alternatives (even if their
face value is sometimes cheaper). "Think local" means that whenever
important
political or business decisions are made, the needs and wishes of the
people
of the Isle of Man should be place above all other considerations. In
short
"think local" means THINK MANX!
What "think local" does not mean,
of course,
is blind support for all retail outlets in the Isle of Man. It does not
mean support for shops owned and often staffed by non-Manx residents,
nor
does it mean support for shops which either don't sell Manx goods where
available or display Manx goods in a half-hearted or somewhat
embarrassed
way.
Government probably has the most
to learn
from the "think local" idea. "Think local" does not mean upgrading or
rebuilding
Government offices while many Government employed manual workers are on
the poverty line; neither does "think local" mean stuffing the civil
service
with the best the UK can provide when Manx graduates and workers should
be employed even if they did require some training! Likewise, "think
local"
does not mean adopting an educationally flawed curriculum from England
when students are being denied Manx language classes and aren't even
offered
classes in general Manx studies.
"Think local" does mean putting
the interests
of the Isle of Man above the interests of greed crazed money launderers
and tax dodgers. "Think local" also means putting Manx residents' views
and wishes above the money craving instincts of the developer and the
property
speculator.
Finance
Sector Policy Review Committee rejects Moffatt's Memorandum
Response to Bernard Moffatt's
Memorandum
of Dissent by the Finance Sector policy Review Committee:
The most serious attack on Mec
Vannin's
recently adopted Finance Sector policy Review Report has come not from
the industry itself or the Manx press but, surprisingly, from Mec
Vannin's
own press officer, Bernard Moffatt.
Mr. Moffatt's views are contained
in a
memorandum of dissent which, without prior consultation, he released at
the same time as the official Mec Vannin press release publicising the
report.
Although the memorandum contains
Mr. Moffatt's
views alone and does not represent any body of opinion within Mec
Vannin
it nonetheless deserves proper consideration and reply if only for the
way it so concisely expresses the "establishment" case for maintaining
and expanding the finance industry in Mann.
The defence of the finance sector
presented
in the memorandum runs thus, and I paraphrase:
If we want a level of material
culture
and state services equal to or greater than that of the U.K., then we
need
to import high value, high growth industries. This is necessary not
only
because our small population makes us incapable of generating the
wealth
ourselves, but also because we have a higher dependency ratio than the
U.K.
We also, so the argument goes on,
need
an industry which doesn't bring in its wake an unacceptable influx of
immigrants
which would threaten our "quality of life". According to the memorandum
(and for that matter the government, the A.P.G., Labour Party. et al.)
the offshore finance industry fits the bill to a tee.
Throughout the memorandum is an
implicit
assumption that the Manx people are incapable of creating an
independent
future for themselves except as servants of imported high growth
industries.
Leaving this aside for a moment, however, the justification of the
finance
sector as presented in the memorandum is still flawed even on its own
terms.
In contradiction of the findings of the Mec Vannin policy report, Mr.
Moffatt
writes:
"The finance sector makes an
important
contribution to the Manx G.N.P. However, its contribution is a
statistical
minority in terms of the economy and the sector is not homogeneous."
Mr. Moffatt makes uncritical use
of the
government statistic which shows that in 1991 the finance industry
employed
13.7% of the workforce, whilst generating a disproportionate 34% of
national
income. From this he makes the erroneous claim that the offshore
industry
therefore creates wealth without stimulating significant immigration
and
damage to our quality of life.
In reality, around 22% of the
working population
and 46% of the economy is reliant on the finance industry. By
artificially
inflating our economy with the through-flow of fugitive international
capital,
the finance sector makes the Isle of Man an attractive market for
economic
colonisation and exploitation by the likes of U.K. and Irish building
firms,
large retailers and others as well as a host individual entrepreneurs.
If the pollution, traffic
congestion in
towns and villages, the destruction of countryside by speculative
housing
developments, the increasingly cut throat competition for work from
incoming
businesses and general substitution of Manx cultural norms by a finance
sector work ethic and pace of life is not an erosion of our quality of
life, then what is?
As to the argument in the
memorandum that
the finance sector is not a monolithic and inherently unstable
industry,
Mr. Moffatt misses the main point made in the official report:
What makes the finance sector an
unreliable
economic partner and benefactor from a Manx point of view, is that it
is
almost wholly owned by and run in the interests of far off
trans-national
corporations, with loyalty only to maximising profit and the ability to
move at will to where it can most easily be made. This makes THEM, not
the Manx government, the real power in the land.
Whilst the finance sector is made
up of
several elements, chiefly banking and insurance, it cannot be claimed
that
the sector is diversified in the sense that any of these elements are
free-standing
and insulated to any degree from each other's economic fortunes. In
fact,
they are about as diversified and heterogeneous as a row of dominoes;
they
stand or fall together depending on whether or not outside interests
continue
to have overall confidence in the stability / servility of the Isle of
Man as an offshore finance centre.
Perhaps the most important issue
raised
by Mr. Moffatt comes in the conclusion to his memorandum:
"The challenge to our
organisation,
Mec Vannin, is not to block economic growth, but to ensure that it does
not translate into a social and cultural nightmare for the Manx Nation."
For a nationalist, the narrowness
of vision
displayed here is astounding. In effect it seems that Mr. Moffatt is
recommending
that Mec Vannin should accept the political and economic agenda of the
current ruling establishment and adopt a merely reactionary role in
order
to limit the social and cultural collateral damage inflicted on the
Manx
people. It is the view of the Finance Sector Review Committee, and
indeed
the membership of Mec Vannin who endorsed its report, that the
nightmare
of growthist economic development is already here and will worsen
considerably
unless a new set of guiding principles and values are adopted at the
heart
of government. As well as vociferously exposing the deficiencies of
government
policies, we believe that Mec Vannin should be actively campaigning to
bring about such a shift in values towards ones which put the Manx
people
at the heart of any development here, rather than the periphery.
Chris Sheard, for and on
behalf of the
finance sector policy review committee.
GROWTH
"Mec Vannin proposes that our
economic
development should be based upon the principle of sustainable economic
growth com-mensurate with our small size and natural population level."
Mec Vannin Policy Document
April
1992.
The traditional economic vision
for the
future is that everyone, in a global human population growing at an
alarming
rate, should aspire to the high consumption, high pollution way of life
of the rich minority. This vision is obviously and hopelessly false and
so we need to define a new sort of economic progress, directed to the
well
being of people and the environment, to quality of life rather than
quantity
of consumption. The new "green economics" must enable people to develop
their own sustainable ways of living, in the context of their own
cultures.
In the Isle of Man, our
politicians, our
people and our entire system of government are locked into the idea of
never ending growth and ever higher consumption, as indeed are
traditional
politicians everywhere.
Fortunately, our policy document
of April
1992 already contains some of the ideas and alternatives that green
economics
puts forward and so we should expand these ideas and ultimately put
forward
an alternative to the stale ideas of "Prosperity Through Growth". Then
we might be able to get across our idea that "growth" in the
traditional
economic sense has a negative downside and is by no means always a
positive
thing.
Paul Kelly.
Miles:
Prospering and caring for Port St. Mary
Harping back to this "Think
Local" thing,
"local" to me means Port Saint Mary. I try to think local when I do my
shopping but, unfortunately, this last 15 years or so has seen the
decimation
of Port Saint Mary as a place to shop. Due to business' "think big
strategies"
and Government's "think little and do even less" approach to preserving
local communities, shopping in Port St. Mary has become very limited.
There
are even those that say that the life and spirit of the community has
been
lost.
Now imagine my astonishment when
I read
in the paper, a few weeks ago, Miles' comment over the opening of
Scoill
Purt le Moirrey. He reckoned that the new school would breath life back
into Port St. Mary and that building the new school was the best thing
that he'd ever done. I've no argument with his words, but hasn't he got
some cheek when he has supposedly been representing Port St. Mary in
the
Keys throughout the period of its rapid decline?
P.A. Gawne, Cultural Officer.
So
that
was 1994 ......
We made an extensive oral and
written submission
to the Committee investigating freedom of information. We decided that
we definitely don't like the finance industry (except for Bernard). We
boycotted Tynwald Fair because of the unnecessary and
belittling presence of HRH, but
turned
up at the last minute to dish out Yn Pabyr Seyr and launch the
Greenfield
Fighting Fund. We upset Dandara by suggesting that the grotesque
despoilation
of our countryside was not dreams becoming reality. We handed out
literature
expressing our views to a group of Swiss lawyers and bankers and upset
Mr. Gilbey. We finally got Archibald Cregeen commemorated (Thanks to
Cathy
Clucas, Reverend Clayton, Yn Cheshaght Ghailckagh, Cubbon's the
stonemasons
and all who helped attend. Illiam Costain went to Brussels and talked
to
Big People and we upset Mr. Gilbey again and did lots of other
things....
Gyn
Shennaghys,
Gyn Ashoonys
Scruit as loayrit magh liorish
Chris
Sheard ec Cronk Hango, Laa Illiam Dhone, 1995.
Ta ny Manninee, myr pobble, gyn
enney erbee
er nyn shennaghys co-chadjin. Cha nee agh shennaghys persoonagh as
mooinjeragh
ta er mayrn as far-chredjue dy row yn shennaghys ain ooilley bentyn
rish
praaseyn, skeddan as boghtynid. Ny smoo na shoh, cha nel eh rieau er ve
cho ymmyrchagh dooin yn shennaghys ain y hoiggal. Shen my varel as shen
cooish yn oraid shoh.
Cre voish haink yn meehushtey
shoh? Ta'n
chooid smoo dy Vanninee er choayl yn shennaghys oc kyndagh rish yn
drogh
chorys-ynsee hooar shin veih ny Sostynee 'sy nuyoo cheead. Ayns ny
scoillyn
cadjin as er lheh 'sy schoill roin jiu, cha nel sheelogheyn dy Vanninee
er n'ynsaghey veg, dy oikoil, mychione nyn gultoor as shennaghys hene.
Agh nagh vel shin lhome-lane dy
hennaghys
as eiraght 'sy traa t'ayn? Jeeagh shiu ayns shapp lioar erbee. As nagh
vel yn reiltys ain jannoo e chooid share dy chur roish y theay skeeal
yn
ashoon ain? Son shickyrys, t'ad g'eearree troggal thieyn-tashtee dy
liooar!
Yiarrin nagh. Yiarrin nagh vel ad
freayll
as soilshaghey magh agh yn ayrn marroo jeh'n chultoor ain; ny shenn
ghreienyn
as aghtyn baghee - yn vleayst follym, ta shen dy ghra. Gys y traa shoh,
cha nel adsyn as pooar oc er chur monney tastey da'n chennaghys
Manninagh.
Cha nel skeeal yn ashoon ain voish cheu ny Manninee er ve clouit noadyr
er dyn bleeantyn jeih as daeed. Agh nish, er-lhiams dy vel caghlaa
scanshoil,
as gaueagh neesht, fo raad.
Lhaih mee lioar-voayrd-caffee
ghloasagh
shiaghtin ny jees er dy henney enmyssit "Moods of Mann". Aynjee va
scruit
ec lhiams-lhiats Manninagh dy row shennaghys giare yn ellan ain myr
b'vie
lesh yn cherroo-argidys (ren g'eeck er-e-son) as yn reiltys soilshaghey
magh eh.
Ta'n ughtar cur roin daa argane
scanshoil.
Hoshiaght, t'eh shirrey prowal nagh beagh agh aght-baghee as cultoor
boght
ec ny Manninee ghooie gyn bree as argid ny Juanyn Haink Noal. S'goan
oddagh
shin er jeet neose veih ny biljyn, t'eh screeu,
gyn yn chooney ocsyn!
'Sy nah ynnyd, t'eh resooney nagh
lhisagh
shinyn, ny Manninee ghooie, ve ro voirit as shinyn nyn myn-vunlught
ayns
y cheer ain pene ny laghyn shoh. Son ooilley, t'eh gra, nagh jig ny
cummaltee
noa dy ve cho Manninagh ayns sheeloghe ny jees as ny Manninee ayns ny
shenn
laghyn jeh sluight ny Loghlynee as ny Sostynee? Shoh sampleyr mie (ny
sie)
jeh'n chennaghys noa ta goll er screeu rere yn reiltys as cooie da'n
cherroo
argidys, chiarnyn noa y cheer ain.
Er my hon hene, ta mee credjal dy
re boghtynid
yn vershoon "oikoil" shoh. Ta mee credjal dy vel yn shennaghys ain
ginsh
dooin skeeal as lessoonyn elley dy bollagh anchasley rish.
Ayns ny laghyn chaie, cha row
rieau slane
verchys as saaseyn yn ellan shoh cc y theay Vanninagh. Va'n chooid
share
dy kinjagh goit ersooyl cc ny reiltee yoarree ain. Cha nee yn cultoor
ain
pene ren freayll ny Manninee ayns boghtynid agh ny drogh lughtyn-reill
harrystoo feie yn chennaghys ain.
Lhisagh shin goaill moyrn, cha
nee nearey
jeh'n aght chum ny shenn Vanninee rish nyn gultoor gyn scansh da'n
vee-reill
shen. Lurg ooilley, cha nee reihys, myr ta paart gra, agh accrys as
genney
hug er ny Manninee nyn jengey as aght baghee y hreigeil 'sy nuyoo
cheead.
Cha duitt yn chenn chultoor Gaelgagh veih-my-cheilley derrey haink shin
fo-reill jeeragh ny Goaldee 'sy vlein shiaght keead jeig, queig as
three
feed as hraast ad y phing yerrinagh ass y cheer.
S'feer gra dy jarroo dy vel shin
ooilley
dy bunneydagh jeh sluight "joarree" ennagh: Gaelgagh, Loghlynnagh,
Sostynagh
as fir elley haink stiagh 'syn ellan thousane, ny keead, ny lieh cheead
bleeaney er dy henney. Agh cha nel whilleen dy chummaltee noa rieau er
jeet stiagh ayns traa cho giare as shoh, as cha nel yn enney Manninagh
as cultoor ain rieau er ve cho faase as nish noadyr. S'breagagh dy
ghra,
er y fa shen, dy vel yn chooid smoo jeu cur bree noa da'n chultoor ain
ny laghyn shoh. S'feer dy ghra dy vel polaseeyn noi-Vanninagh y reiltys
ta tayrn stiagh whilleen dy yoarreeyn, marroo yn cultoor ain as dy vel
ad cur er bun ayns ynnyd jeh fer smessey, neu-Vanninagh.
Spooill ny Goaldee yn cultoor
dooghyssagh
ain sy nuyoo cheead agh ren ad jeeill foddey ny smessey na shen dooin.
Hug ad dooin yn corys-ynsee Sostynagh as chaill shin son y chooid smoo,
nyn shennaghys as enney ashoonagh cadjin kyndagh rish.
Shen y fa, ta mee credjal, nagh
vel eh
er jeet lesh yn ghleayshaght ashooneyragh ec traa ny reihyssyn cadjin.
Ta ny far-ashooneyryn 'sy reiltys gra dy vel daa raad ynrican da ny
Manninee;
yn raad ocsyn ny yn raad er-ash da laghyn praaseyn as skeddan. Kyndagh
rish keead blein dy vee ynsaghys ta ymmodee Manninee credjal yn reih
shoh
as t'ad jiooldey yn cultoor ocsyn.
Dy firrinagh, ta'n shennaghys ain
g'ynsaghey
dooin dy re breagagh yn reih shoh. T'eh g'ynsaghey dooin, dy firrinagh,
dy beagh aght-baghee souyr dy liooar da ny Manninee ayns Mannin dy
beagh
slane seyrsnys politickagh ain as slane niart ain er saaseyn as berchys
ooilley nyn jeer hene.
Cha jeanmayd scapail veih'n
scadoo ta ny
bleeantyn shiaght keead jeig queig as three feed, as hoght keead jeig
daa-yeig
as three feed foast ceau orrin derrey vees firrinys y hennaghys ain
currit
roish y theay.
S'liklee nagh bee yn curriglym
Sostynagh
ayns ny scoillyn ceaut ersooyl dy gerrid. Er y fa shen, t'eh orrin
pene,
ny ashooneyryn, soilshaghey magh yn shennaghys Manninagh firrinagh ayns
aght erbee oddysmayd cooie da'n phobble; er lheh, er lhiams, ayns
arraneyn
as cloieyn myr ren ny Gaelgeyryn ayns Nalbin dy speeideilagh kuse dy
vleeantyn
er dy henney.
Chaill shin nyn gredjue ayndooin
pene myr
pobble er lheh 'sy lhing choloinagh Ghoaldagh as cha nirreemayds reesht
myr ashoon Manninagh derrey vees yn credjue shen currit er bun reesht.
Without
History, Without Nationhood
A translation of the Manx
speech by
Chris Sheard, Delivered at Hango Hill on the 2nd January, 1995.
The Manx, as a people, have no
knowledge
of their collective -history. Only individual and family history
remains
as well as the misbelief that our history is all "spuds 'n' herrin'"
and
poverty. What's more, it has never been so important that we understand
our history. That's my view and that is the subject of this speech.
Where did this ignorance come
from? Most
people have lost their Manx history because of the pernicious education
system given to us by the English in the 19th century. In the ordinary
schools, and especially in the school before us today (King William's
College),
generations of Manx people have learnt nothing officially of their own
native culture and history.
But aren't we overflowing with
history
and heritage these days? Look in any book-shop. And isn't our
government
doing its best to present to the people, the story of our nation? They
certainly want to build enough museums!
I would say not. I would say that
they
only preserve the dead part of our culture; the old implements and ways
of life - the empty husk, that is. Up till now, those in power haven't
paid much attention to Manx history. Neither has a Manx history, from a
Manx point of view, been published since the '50s. But now, I believe,
an important and dangerous change is underway.
I read a glossy, coffee-table
book a couple
of weeks ago entitled "Moods of Mann". In it was written a short
history
of our island as the finance sector (who paid for it) and the
government
would like it to be seen.
The author presents us with two
arguments:
Firstly, he tries to prove that without the vigour and money of the
come-overs,
now and in former times, the native Manx would only have a poor culture
and way of life.
Without their help, he writes,
we'd still
be in the trees.
Secondly he argues that we, the
native
Manx, shouldn't be too bothered that we are now an ethnic minority in
our
own country. After all, he says, won't the new residents become as
Manx,
in a generation or two, as the Manx people in former times of Viking
and
English origin?
This is a good example of the new
history
according to the government and agreeable to the finance sector, the
new
lords of our land.
Myself, I think this "official"
version
is rubbish. I believe that our history tells us another story and other
lessons, completely contrary to those that are being written now.
In the past, the ordinary Manx
people never
had the benefit of all the wealth and resources of this island. The
best
part was always creamed off by our foreign rulers. It wasn't our own
culture
which kept the Manx in poverty, but the bad rulers over them throughout
our history.
We ought to be proud, not
ashamed, of the
way the old Manx people held on to their culture in spite of this
mis-rule.
After all it wasn't choice, as some say, but the hunger and want
inflicted
upon the Manx that forced them to abandon their language and way of
life
in the 19th century. The old Gaelic culture didn't fall apart until we
came under the direct rule of the British in the year 1765, and they
squeezed
the land dry.
It's true indeed that we are all
originally
of "foreign" descent; Gaelic, Viking, English and others, who came to
the
island a thousand, a hundred, or fifty years ago. But never have so
many
new residents come in such a short space of time as now, and never have
our Manx identity and culture been so weak as they are now either.
It's false to claim, therefore,
that the
majority of them are reinvigorating our culture these days. It's true
to
say that the anti-Manx policies of the government, which draw so many
foreigners,
are killing our culture with one worse, and un-Manx.
The British wrecked our native
culture
in the 19th century, but they did far worse harm to us than this. They
gave us the English education system and we lost, for the most part,
our
history and collective national identity because of it.
That is why, I believe, the
nationalists
have not been as successful at election time as they should have been.
The "nationalists" (in name only) in the government say that there are
only two roads for the Manx: Their road or the road back to "spuds 'n'
herrin'". Because of 100 years of miseducation, many Manx give credence
to the former choice and they reject their culture.
In truth, our history teaches us
that this
choice is a false one. It teaches us, really, that the Manx people
could
live comfortably in Mann if we had full political freedom and control
of
all the resources and wealth of our own country.
We won't escape from the shadow
that the
years 1765 and 1872 still cast over us until the truth of our history
is
made known to the people.
It is likely that the English
National
Curriculum will be with us for some while yet. Therefore, it's up to
us,
the nationalists, to set forth the real Manx history in any accessible
way we can - especially, I think, through songs and plays as the Gaelic
speakers in Scotland did a few years ago.
We lost belief in ourselves as a
separate
people under British colonial rule and we won't rise again as a Manx
nation
until that belief is re-established.
English
Oration - Illiam Dhone Day 1995
By Paul Kelly
In less than two years time the
Isle of
Man will be facing another General Election and although hope springs
eternal,
I know and you know that we are almost certainly bound to be
disappointed
if we are expecting some sort of democratic revolution in which the
entire
old Guard are swept out of office and replaced, out of the blue, by men
and women committed to rescuing the Manx people from a bleak future as
a marginalised minority in some offshore, second division banking and
insurance
bolt hole.
I am sure I am not alone here
today in
dreaming of a result where every candidate who ever refers to the Isle
of Man as being, "like a limited company in which we are the
shareholders"
gets their true come-uppance and any M.H.K. who ever considers that
past
experience in running their own business is good qualification for
being
in Government is slung out of office and replaced by people with
political
ideals who might perhaps set their sights a little higher and reach out
to the hearts and minds of the Manx nation.
I do not suppose that I am alone
either
in yearning for a result which sees the back of all those who think
that
"progress" lies in allowing huge housing developments to sprawl across
our green fields, or in an ever-increasing number of cars on the roads,
or in constructing a hospital inside the TT course and a fly-over
across
a valley to reach it, or for that matter, in demolishing graceful
buildings
to replace them with office blocks. No, I am certain I am not alone in
wishing to see them voted out, along with all those whose obsession it
is to turn beauty into power.
However, it is clear that wishing
and hoping
or dreaming will not be enough. The reality is there will be NO change
until the right people are in the House or, at the very least, some of
the right people are and I am sure that it is the role of Mec Vannin to
try to achieve that.
I believe Manx people
increasingly see
M.H.K.'s as having lost touch with the electorate. This is particularly
so in the case of Ministers, who take decisions behind closed doors on
matters which never appeared in their own original manifestos. Many of
us in Mec Vannin feel that the Ministerial system of government that is
now in place and especially the power of political patronage in the
hands
of the Chief Minister has been a disaster for the Manx people.
The situation at present is that
the great
majority of our M.H.K.s stand and are elected as Independents. They
then
elect a Chief Minister (over which the electorate has no say) who in
turn
selects his or her Council of Ministers. Then, and this is the clever
part,
this Council of Ministers issues a Manifesto in the shape of the
Government
Policy Document! Ask yourself, "what kind of Government issues a
manifesto
after being elected? What kind of M.H.K. stands as an independent and
then
compromises that independence by becoming a Minister?"
Strangely, you may think, they
are then
entitled to be addressed as "honourable" members!
You may say that is democracy, we
voted
them in and we should let them get on with it, well, yes, the House of
Keys is democratically elected but we should not pretend that it is
representative
of the Manx electorate. How can it possibly be when, for example, only
one member out of 24 is a woman? Only one member out of 24 is under 40
years old? BUT more than twelve members out of 24 have business
interests.
So then, how can Mec Vannin
change any
of this? Ultimately only by putting up candidates at local and national
level and getting them elected. I realise this means overcoming
obstacles,
not least of which is our own antipathy to traditional politics, but I
also know there is a considerable number of young Mec Vannin activists
who have the heart felt commitment, integrity and ability to make a
radical
change to the House of Keys, and therefore to Government, if elected.
Whilst
it is for the membership to decide the contents of a future Mec Vannin
election manifesto our existing Policy Document contains a number of
principles
which I know will not be compromised. Our manifesto should make no
concessions
on the priority we give to the environment for example. Nor should we
be
tempted to adapt our policy of ending allegiance to the British Crown
to
what some might consider a less controversial stance. A Bill of Rights
Act and a Freedom of Information Act are also both essential. Our
manifesto
must also address the problem of how we restrict rapid population
growth
from outside, without the racist overtones of immigration control.
I am convinced that it is now
essential
that we commit ourselves bath to fielding candidates in future
elections
and to preparing a manifesto that sets out clearly and honestly what
Mec
Vannin stands for. If we set ourselves even the modest target of, say,
six candidates standing, then I think we will see, at the very least, a
shift in the debate in our direction and we could even be in the
position
of setting the agenda for the 1996 General Election.
The
Offshore Lancashire Times
No 938467812 Average weekly
circulation
in excess of 250,000
Price 10 IOM
ECU
14 November 2094
I.O.M. Plc in
merger talks
with Channel Islands Plc?
A source within Government has
revealed
that top level talks have taken place between the Board of Directors of
the Channel Island Government and the Island's Council of Directors.
The traditional commercial links
between
the Channel Islands and the Island could now take a formal footing, if
the story is true. Many Island residents regard the Channel Islands as
the "Old Home Country" and have brought many of their customs and
traditions
with them, such as tax evasion and driving at 25 mph.
Questioned about a possible loss
of independence
or identity, Chief Minister Richard Dork said, "I regard this as a
positive
development. Residents of IOM Plc would become beneficial shareholders
in Channel Islands Plc. A reciprocal agreement would have to be
thrashed
out, of
Continued on Page 9 (There
was
only one page)
Last Native
Manxman's
Statue to Memory of Manx People
Chief Minister Richard Dork
unveiled the
statue of the last true Manxman on Tuesday of this week. Manxman Juan
Kermeen,
lately of Peel, died aged 101 earlier this year. His statue will join
those
of fellow Manx men, Norman Wisdom, Nigel Mansell, George Formby,
President
Dan Quayle and Albert Gubay in the Villa Marina Garden of Statues.
After
the unveiling, Mr. Dork said, "There has been a small but vociferous
minority
who have claimed that this is a sad occasion. I prefer to think that
there
is a positive aspect to this. Of course we should remember our heritage
in simple, cost effective fashion such as this, but we must not allow
any
sentimentality to get in the way of economic growth.
"The passing of Mr. Kermeen has
removed
an impediment under international law that made us pay undue regard to
native peoples. The way is now clear to progress the full development
of
the Independent Offshore State of Man without the negative attitude of
the Manx Crabs."
Inside this
week's super
O.L.T.
WHY WE MUST EXPAND OUR
FINANCE SECTOR
- BUSINESS PAGES
ENTREPRENEUR BEQUEATHS MONEY
TO
FINISH IRIS PROJECT - PAGE 7
JOB VACANCIES FOR BOOKKEEPERS
AND
ACCOUNTANTS -PAGE 38.
Albert Gubay
Memorial
Hospital
END OF SEASON SPECIAL OFFERS
A "snip" at HALF the price!
Try our new super-quick vasectomy at
a
massive 50% reduction on normal prices (vouchers also accepted).
ALSO --CAN'T BELIEVE YOUR EARS?
Sticky-out
ears pinned back at 20% reduction.
Two For The
Price of One.
The Isle of Man's main hospital
at Ballamona
is offering two operations for the price of one this month. The
hospital
which was built with money from the Isle of Man pension fun is offering
all voucher holders the option, of two minor operations, such as
ingrowing
toenails, piles, "the snip", etc. The hospital used all of the pension
fund by the time it was completed in the year 2000, but the D.H.S.S.
kindly
offered pension fund contributors valuable and useful vouchers instead
which could be redeemed in exchange for various medical services /
procedures
at any of the Island's hospitals.
Small Fry
The last known surviving breeding
pair
of herring (Juan and Mona) have produced an offspring.
The fish, christened Gorry by
excited herring
keepers, is being tended round the clock to give it every chance of
survival.
Meanwhile, D.A.F.T. Minister Joe
Corrin
has vehemently denied a rumour that it is planned to sell Gorry to a
travelling
aquarium.
Our investigative reporter Paul
Grammar
has discovered, however, that Gorry will instead go to the Scientific
Fish
and Chip Shops fast food chain in Belfast. Under the Privatisation of
Government
Departments Act 2004, an Act resulting from the "Prosperity Through
Groves'
report of 1999, Government departments are compelled to sell assets to
the highest bidder.
Coastal
Erosion Threatens
T.T. Course
Kirk Michael is falling into the
sea, threatening
to take the T.T. course and several Dandara estates with it.
Chief Minister Richard Dork is
undisturbed
by the revelation, however. Questioned at Friday morning's press
conference,
he stated, "I actually regard this as quite a positive development. The
need for replacement housing stock will provide a much needed boost to
our building industry and I've heard that there's some undeveloped land
above the smog line at the Veranda. Also, we plan to implement "Time
for
Change" which was shelved a hundred years ago. Kirk Michael
Commissioners
were very much opposed and their disappearance will ease things
greatly."
|